Saturday, September 9, 2017

‘A narrower education: Moves to transfer polytechnic schemes and architecture institutions out of HRD ministry are disturbing signals’ by Ashok Thakur:




 Ashok Thakur

How one thought leads to another. I was remembering my dear old friend Ashok Thakur today- this being his birthday. And the next moment I remembered that a few months back he had sent me an article written by him.

Feeling sheepish I read the article today very belatedly-  ‘A narrower education: Moves to transfer polytechnic schemes and architecture institutions out of HRD ministry are disturbing signals’. Ashok, a serious thinking bureaucrat from the IAS, is an Ex-Secretary from the Higher Education Department and a dear friend of mine.

He starts by telling us about an order on this subject issued by the Cabinet Secretary. Weather the Cabinet Secretary had consulted Secretary Higher Education and  other experts in  the matter before passing this order is not clear. Nor does one know if the Secretary Higher Education took the file back to the Cabinet Secretary and requested him to take a re look at the implications. And that you and I, the so-called well read people, did not find time to discuss these vital issues completes the picture. 

I have known Ashok since our days in France- 35 years back. And talking about France, one thing that had struck us on reaching  France was the active involvement of the people in the issues of education, not only of higher education, but also and even more so, of the school education. And here we are that we let the important issues pass without having a public debate over it. 


 I would suggest all to read this very thought provoking article . I am sure some experts would present counter arguments to what Ashok has epoused, but then let us at least get into a debate. 

And lastly, Happy birthday Ashok. 


 
‘A narrower education: Moves to transfer polytechnic schemes and architecture institutions out of HRD ministry are disturbing signals’ by Ashok Thakur. http://indianexpress.com/article/opinion/columns/a-narrower-education/

Thursday, September 7, 2017

"Thanks to demonetisation, India has reaped huge economic benefits” by Jug Suraiya



 


Photo source: ndtv


It starts like this, "Two bhakts exchanging notes – pun not intended – on the merits of demonetisation....". If you like Jug Suraiya's kind of humour, then read on...


“Minting money: Thanks to demonetisation, India has reaped huge economic benefits” by  Jug Suraiya

 https://blogs.timesofindia.indiatimes.com/jugglebandhi/minting-money-thanks-to-demonetisation-india-has-reaped-huge-economic-benefits-f0-9f-98-9c/

'Safety First, Speed later and Beautification of railway stations much, much later' by K.J.S.Chatrath

Photo source: Financial Express

Rajdhani derails near New Delhi station, third city mishap in 32 days (Times of India, 8th September, 2017) - News.

I am a regular travelller by trains in India. I would request the authorities to lay emphasis on rail safety first, speed can come later and beautification of railway stations much, much later.

Just because France, Japan & China have trains running at over 300 kms an hour is no argument to copy them while our existing vast railway infrastructure remains unsafe.

The main component of train journey is the time spent in the train while it moves from the starting town to the destination town. Trying to spend millions, by taking foreign loans, on making the railway stations look like those in France, Japan & China is a case of wrong priorities. Emphasis should be on making the train journeys safe, punctual and clean.

Taking loans from foreign countries to run trains at 300 kms an hour, when the rough calculations show that the revenue earning model of such attempts would be pathetic, forcing subsidization for rich to travel min such trains and the burden will fall on the poor 2nd class passenger to fund the subsidization.  

"Another slogan 'Swachh Sanklap Se Swachh Siddhi'"........K.J.S.Chatrath

We have been blessed with another slogan 'Swachh Sanklap Se Swachh Siddhi' (स्वच्छ संकलप से स्वच्छ सिद्धि )

But please don't ask me what it means!

Sunday, September 3, 2017